What is the difference between prestressed concrete and reinforced concrete?

The article aims to answer the question “What is the difference between prestressed concrete and reinforced concrete?”. It will also discuss what reinforced concrete and prestressed concretes are. Read on to know more: 

What is the difference between prestressed concrete and reinforced concrete?

Continue reading the article to understand the difference between prestressed concrete and reinforced concrete.

Compressive and tensile stresses in typical reinforced cement concrete are absorbed by the concrete and steel, respectively. Because it is tensionally weak, the concrete below the neutral axis is disregarded. 

The concrete in the tensile zone develops tiny fractures even though steel absorbs the tensile pressures. If steel and concrete are both strained before applying external stresses, the load-bearing capacity of such concrete sections may be enhanced. 

The idea behind prestressed concrete is as follows. According to the ACI committee, prestressed concrete is a kind of concrete in which enough internal stresses are added so that the stresses brought on by external loadings may be reduced to the required extent.

Prestress created in R.C.C. members is compressive in nature to balance the tensile stresses brought on by external loads. It increases the effectiveness of the whole section—including the concrete region in the tension zone—in withstanding weights.

Prestress is often added to reinforced concrete by tensioning the reinforcement. So, when external loads would typically result in tensile strains, compression is created. If a rectangular prestressed concrete beam experiences a prestressing force P at the centroidal axis A consistent compressive stress of “P/A” will be produced in concrete as a result of this force.

Because their yield strength is not particularly great, ordinary mild steel and deformed bars, which are used in RCC, are not utilized in PSC (prestressed concrete). Numerous variables contribute to the 20% prestress loss in prestressed concrete. 

When using mild steel or HYSD bars, very little prestress will remain after the losses, rendering it useless. As a result, steel with high tensile strength is employed for prestressing. The steel used in prestressing has to have a greater ultimate elongation in addition to its high strength.

Following are the comparison points between prestressed and reinforced concrete:

  • Concrete on the compression side of the neutral side of the axis of an RCC beam is sufficient on its own. The concrete on the neutral axis’ tension side is useless. However, the whole portion works in the prestressed concrete beam.
  • Beams made of reinforced concrete are typically hefty. In addition to the longitudinal reinforcement for flexure, they always need shear reinforcements. Beams made of prestressed concrete are lighter. A significant portion of the shear is resisted by the presence of the bent tendons and the pre-compression.
  • High-strength concrete is not required for reinforced concrete beams. However, high-strength concrete and high-strength steel are required for prestressed concrete beams. To withstand high stresses at the anchorages, high-strength concrete is required. To transmit a significant prestressing force, high-strength steel is required.
  • Due to their size and weight, reinforced concrete beams are better suited in circumstances when weight is more important than strength. For heavier weights and longer spans, prestressed concrete beams are a great option. 
  • They are thin, making creative treatments simple to apply. Working loads do not cause cracks to form. Even if a little fracture forms when something is overloaded, the crack closes once the stress is gone. The prestressed concrete beams seldom ever deflect.
  • There is no means to test the steel and the concrete in reinforced concrete beams. Steel and concrete may be tested in prestressed concrete beams while they are being stretched.

What is reinforced concrete?

In construction, reinforced concrete, or RC, is a composite material. By including reinforcing steel bars with better tensile strength and ductility, the concrete’s poor tensile strength and ductility are strengthened. 

Steel bars are inserted within formwork during construction before concrete is poured. Rebar may also be previously wired into a steel cage configuration. The formwork is subsequently filled with new concrete, which is then vibrated to eliminate air pockets and ensure that the particles are properly consolidated. To achieve a solid binding, it is essential that the concrete fully encircles each bar.

Due to the versatility, strength, and accessibility of its raw ingredients, reinforced concrete is frequently employed. It is mostly employed as the primary structural components of buildings, homes, dams, bridges, and other similar constructions, such as columns, piers, piles, beams, slabs, and footings. 

Because reinforced concrete fills the container it is supporting, it may be readily shaped into unusual forms. As a result, elaborate architectural structures may be created that would be challenging to construct with conventional materials, such as wood or steel. 

In addition, reinforced concrete is often utilized in public works projects to build sidewalks and highway pavement. Steel bars used to reinforce the concrete provide the composite section tensile strength, making it possible to create a sturdy and practical composite construction material.

What is prestressed concrete?

To put it simply, Prestressed is concrete that has been stressed. Placed in a form, reinforcement bars are strained by being stretched at either end, creating tension in the bar. While the bars are being stretched, concrete is poured into the form and all around them. 

The steel seeks to resume its shorter length when released, adding a compressive force to the concrete that makes it strong enough to cover greater distances than typical reinforced concrete.

In large-scale construction projects like erecting highway overpasses and commercial structures, prestressing is utilized to create composite beams and piers. Without such reinforcement, concrete’s lack of tensile strength would lead it to collapse without support in the center. 

As a result, it allows a concrete beam to carry a weight between piers on each side.

Conclusion 

Although not required for every commercial project, prestressed concrete may enable you to build buildings that you didn’t believe were feasible with concrete. Curves, columns, arches, and other structural forms that are often challenging to construct with reinforced concrete alone may be made by fitting together these pre-cast pieces like a jigsaw. 

We at Southport Concrete Corp can assist you in determining if it is the best material for your construction if you provide us with the specifics of your project.

Frequently asked questions (FAQS): What is the difference between prestressed concrete and reinforced concrete?

What is the difference between prestressed concrete and reinforced concrete?

Compressive and tensile stresses in typical reinforced cement concrete are absorbed by the concrete and steel, respectively. Because it is tensionally weak, the concrete below the neutral axis is disregarded. 

The concrete in the tensile zone develops tiny fractures even though steel absorbs the tensile pressures. If steel and concrete are both strained before applying external stresses, the load-bearing capacity of such concrete sections may be enhanced. The idea behind prestressed concrete is as follows. 

According to the ACI committee, prestressed concrete is a kind of concrete in which enough internal stresses are added so that the stresses brought on by external loadings may be reduced to the required extent. 

What is reinforced concrete?

In construction, reinforced concrete, or RC, is a composite material. By including reinforcing steel bars with better tensile strength and ductility, the concrete’s poor tensile strength and ductility are strengthened. 

Steel bars are inserted within formwork during construction before concrete is poured. Rebar may also be previously wired into a steel cage configuration. The formwork is subsequently filled with new concrete, which is then vibrated to eliminate air pockets and ensure that the particles are properly consolidated. To achieve a solid binding, it is essential that the concrete fully encircles each bar.

Bibliography

What is the difference between prestressed and reinforced concrete? Retrieved from: https://engineeringdiscoveries.com/what-is-the-difference-between-reinforced-concrete-and-prestressed-concrete/

What was missing from this post which could have made it better?

Leave a Comment